close
close
Colts QB Anthony Richardson retired in the fourth of eight career NFL games

INDIANAPOLIS – Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson isn’t the only one who plays like that. He is who he is, a linebacker dressed as a quarterback, but it’s not like he can’t throw the ball. He may throw. You saw him on the first two drives of the Colts’ 27-24 win on Sunday against the Pittsburgh Steelers. He was shooting like an expert before getting injured and exiting in his fourth game in eight career NFL starts, and if you’re not sure you read that correctly, be sure to go back and read it again . Here:

Since being drafted No. 4 overall in the 2023 NFL Draft, Anthony Richardson has started eight games for the Indianapolis Colts. He couldn’t finish half of it.

This makes Sunday the youngest in the Colts’ 50-50 franchise quarterback rotation. Maybe Richardson will be one of the most dominant players in the league, maybe not. It could go either way. Maybe he’ll lead the Colts to a Super Bowl that eluded his predecessor, Andrew Luck, before Luck was forced into retirement in 2019. Maybe not. This could go either way too.

Perhaps Richardson will return this week when the 2-2 Colts — who are on a two-game winning streak after that tumultuous triumph against the Steelers — make their annual visit to Jacksonville. Maybe not. Too early to tell, coach Shane Steichen said after Richardson was diagnosed with a hip injury. Richardson agreed to the 50-50 offer representing his availability against the Jaguars: Maybe, he said. Maybe not.

“I don’t know,” Richardson said. “We have to see what they say. My hip is a little sore at the moment.”

More: What Colts QB Anthony Richardson said after the game about his hip injury

Insider: 10 thoughts from the Colts on Anthony Richardson’s injury and a 27-24 win over the Steelers

Now is not the time for Colts fans to wring their hands over his style of play or the way the Colts use him. Neither will change — and even if the Colts were inclined to bubble-wrap their most important asset, Richardson wouldn’t agree. He was questioned twice about sliding. This is how it went:

Do you regret not slipping away on this piece?

“No, not really,” Richardson said. “It’s football. I had a feeling he was going to beat me anyway, so let’s get started.”

Bigger Picture: Should You Slip More Often?

“I don’t know,” he said. “It’s football. Some people might say I do, some people might say I don’t, but (expletive) I don’t know, man. It’s football.”

Richardson is 6-4, 260 pounds. He’s going to play how he’s going to play. Either he will survive the chaos of trying to run over defenders or he won’t. This is his second season. His career could be long.

Then again, maybe it isn’t.

It could go either way.

Dirty Minkah Fitzpatrick gets his guy(s)

The Colts team that beat the Steelers on Sunday was weak in the middle. Pro Bowl center Ryan Kelly was inactive due to a neck injury. Richardson played less than a full quarter. Running back Jonathan Taylor, who gained a masterful 88 yards on 21 carries, also didn’t finish the game. He twisted his ankle midway through the fourth quarter. I taped it off on the sideline but couldn’t get back into the game.

That was rookie Tanor Bortolini at center for the Colts, replacing backup quarterback and 17-year veteran Joe Flacco, who turned the job over to backup running back Trey Sermon. It wasn’t exactly pretty, but the lights on the scoreboard at Lucas Oil Stadium still told a nice story:

Colts 27, Steelers 24. Thanks for coming, go home safe and so on.

“Great team win, I’ll tell you what,” Steichen began his opening speech. “The boys were resilient the whole time. We knew it was going to be a fist fight against these guys.”

Speaking of Minkah Fitzpatrick.

It was Fitzpatrick, the Steelers’ safety-killer, who later delivered a dirty personal foul shot to Colts receiver Adonai Mitchell that knocked Richardson out of the game the first time around and finished him off a few minutes later. The first strike was clean, if brutal, a shot to the hip from Richardson that caused him to grimace and drop the football because the pain was just too much, even though Bortolini ran across the field – Richardson had fought for a 16-yard gain before the Fitzpatrick score – to recover the fumble.

Fitzpatrick’s second hit was brutal and not clean. This one came three snaps after the first score, when Richardson went to the sideline for two plays and then returned. Sure enough, on his first play, the Colts called a zone read and Richardson elected to keep the ball. He faked the handoff to Taylor, broke off the left edge and felt something in his hip. He was about to go down – giving himself up, as they call it – and had slipped to one knee when Fitzpatrick hit him with a helmet-to-helmet blow.

Afterward, referee Land Clark told a pool reporter that Fitzpatrick’s hit was “accidental” and “was not strong enough to warrant a flag.”

The quarterback slips and gets hit anyway. In your head. On the defender’s helmet. What would it take to “justify a flag”? A trip to the intensive care unit?

As we ask questions, here’s what you’ll be wondering: Why did the Colts let Richardson run the ball on the first snap after he was thrown out of the game?

“They went to base defense,” Steichen said of Richardson’s first play, “and he said he felt good about it. That was the look we had for it.”

Why does this keep happening to Richardson? It’s all there:

Richardson said he was ready to go…and that’s how the Colts looked at this particular defense.

This will continue to happen because Richardson knows no other way — and because the Colts didn’t design this sledgehammer with the speed of a sprinter to stand in the pocket like Dan Marino.

Is this a wise approach? Depends on what happens next week and the next and the next. And next season and the next and the next.

Could go either way, every single Sunday until it’s over. In a way.

Zaire Franklin attacks Najee Harris on Twitter

Here’s the thing: Before the injury, Richardson and this Colts offense were playing great. He had a moment that wasn’t great – he had a moment that was weirdly bad – but that just means he gave us the full Anthony Richardson experience in less than a quarter of the way through.

On the first play of the game, he hit a 32-yard pass to Michael Pittman Jr. Pittman wasn’t exactly open, but Richardson threw it so hard, so perfectly, that only Pittman could hit it. After that, as it became known, a Steelers defense that entered the game ranked first in the NFL in yards allowed (229.7 per game) and points allowed (8.7) was on their heels. Taylor carried it 14 yards, then 4 more yards. Then Richardson badly missed Pittman on a short throw, which he does, before ripping off a 9-yard QB draw – which he does – and then handing off to Taylor three more times, the third time resulting in a touchdown had.

The Colts offense was smoking and things were heating up. Next drive, first play: Richardson hits a 28-yard pass to Pittman, then an 11-yard pass to Josh Downs, then climbs into the open field and has gained 16 yards, the defenders are closing in and he doesn’t slip. He looks for contact, and Fitzpatrick obliges, and soon Flacco comes in for two plays – and then for the rest of the game.

This all seems so familiar to me. Richardson was forced to miss his first career start, the 2023 opener against Jacksonville, with a knee injury. He left his second game against Houston with a concussion. He missed the third game (concussion protocol), played the fourth, and exited his fifth game against Tennessee with a shoulder injury that ended his season.

Richardson knows the story better than anyone.

“I thought, ‘Oh damn, man – not again,'” he said.

This was Richardson’s first injury of the season after suffering three game-winning injuries in 16 rushing attempts last year. Read a statistic like that or read social media – where experts who wouldn’t know the first thing about toughness read snarky words like “…” he is soft – and you would wonder if Richardson is, I don’t know, injury prone. Make the mistake of suggesting something like that to Colts linebacker Zaire Franklin and he will enlighten you.

Franklin was on one after the game, reacting on Twitter to a picture of Steelers running back Najee Harris tricking the crowd at Lucas Oil Stadium by writing:

Child is soft. 84 (Steelers backup RB Cordarrelle Patterson) runs harder.

So Franklin wasn’t in the mood for anything stupid when I awkwardly asked if he wanted to play with a quarterback “who gets hurt all the time.”

“I wouldn’t say he hurts himself all the time,” Franklin said kindly but firmly. “It’s the game we play. It’s a physical game. At the same time, he is our leader, he is our quarterback. I know if he could have gone there he would have. Obviously we see how efficient and good he is when he’s out there.”

We see that, and it doesn’t feel selfish to say: We’d like to see it more often. On Sunday, in less than a quarter, Richardson played three plays into the season against the NFL’s No. 1 defense, was 3-for-4 for 71 yards passing and had three carries for 24 yards. Small sample size and all, but he was trending toward the biggest game of his life, somewhere in the region of 300 yards passing and 100 yards rushing.

Instead, Richardson lay on the field while the home crowd remained silent, watching film we’d seen before – four times in his eight NFL games – and wondering how much more Richardson could take. Will he return Sunday against Jacksonville? Does he end the season? Will he ever become what we all know he could become if he could just stay healthy?

(expletive), I don’t know, man. It’s football.

Find IndyStar columnist Gregg Doyel on Twitter at @GreggDoyelStar or at www.facebook.com/greggdoyelstar.

More: Join the text conversation with sports columnist Gregg Doyel for insights, reader questions and behind-the-scenes insights from Doyel.

By Jasper

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *